Microtransactions. . . Say it out loud. Say it slow. It feels almost disgusting, right? The ultimate dirty word in the gaming industry at the moment. Especially now, in the wake of the whole Battlefront 2 loot box controversy.

Ever since their introduction, microtransactions have been a topic of growing contention among developers and gamers. Some think they’re just a natural step in the process of developers making money, others view it as an encroachment on the industry. Some developers vehemently defend the practice. Others, like good ol’ CD Projekt Red have slammed it as unnecessary greedy.

I think it’s important to figure out the place of microtransactions because they’re such a common practice now. And if we don’t define their appropriate role in the industry then they’re likely to spread where they don’t belong. So where do MTs actually belong in the gaming industry?

The question’s pertinence seems to have reached a boiling point now that even some U.S. government officials are speaking out against lootboxes, saying that they’re “predatory practices” in video games. And this invites a whole Pandora’s box of issues regarding government interference that I won’t get into.

1910557

Do MTs really belong in the trash? Well, maybe they do. But I think the fatalistic reality is that we’re stuck with them. It’s not a practice that will ever completely go away. Not so long as people continue to spend money on games that have them and money on the transactions themselves. And are you really willing to boycott every single game that contains some semblance of paid content inside it? My guess would be no. And if you are, then more power to you.

Some people make the argument that developers need the MTs as a way to actually make a profit from the game. The problem is that there’s not enough evidence that this is the case. There are a lot of games getting by perfectly fine without them. Naturally The Witcher 3 comes to mind, along with plenty of other smaller titles like inFamous, Cuphead, Horizon Zero Dawn, etc.

So if we’re stuck with MTs but they’re not absolutely necessary to the industry, where do we draw the lines? What is and isn’t acceptable?

My opinion is this: Games should not be modified to encourage microtransaction purchases.

“Pay to win” is a garbage concept that should be done away with. Loot boxes are also something that should, arguably, be cast aside in favor of good old in-game grinding. Games are about gaming and the sense of fun and fulfillment that come with progressing. If you can just pay to move forward, a lot of what’s at the heart of playing through the challenges is cast aside.

Then what kind of MT is acceptable? I don’t think the average gamer minds a couple DLC weapons that are cool and don’t tip the balance of the game. Aesthetic things like masks, patches, costumes, are also perfectly fine. It’s always nice to get some little artistic upgrades to your multiplayer character with that last dollar on your store credit.

And I don’t believe it’s morally reprehensible in and of itself to attempt to further profit off your work. Car dealers charge you extra for some custom features as well and we consider that perfectly acceptable. But if the car doesn’t work the way it should “out of the box,” so to speak, without extra payments then we have a problem with that. And in the same way, if the game is tilted to such a point that spending money on MTs is necessary to make the game feel complete we should take issue with it.

Where do microtransactions belong? Ultimately their place is to the side as an optional add-on. With the key word being “optional.” I don’t believe they’re the moral blight on the industry that some people might make them out to be, but nor are they a practice that should be encouraged.

Advertisements

2 Comments »

  1. They belong in the garbage.

    Well I think in free to play games it’s okay but even then, it’s important how they do that.
    Something like LoL I always thought was a fair system. You need your money somehow and if you wanna sell cosmetic stuff in your free to play game, then that’s okay.

    I’m a little iffy for them in MMO games. If the game is updated regularly and gets free content, then cosmetic microtransactions are also fine I believe.

    However, in any other case it shouldn’t be fine. Sadly, many games have microtransactions and as a result the game balance is altered to push people to pay more than 60 bucks.

    The AAA game industry likes to be Hollywood with its games. Cinematic this and what not. I always saw the microtransactions to a game like popcorn to a movie. The industry treats it more like if you don’t pay microtransactions, you can still watch the movie … outside though. Through a window … that’s dirty …. in the rain. It’s bullshit.

    Like

    • I definitely see where you’re coming from. In fact I think I mostly agree with you. If it were up to me I’d remove them entirely from paid games. My piece is more geared towards the unfortunate reality that they’re here and likely here to stay.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s